
LPPFusion’s business plan has long included the intention to have an initial public offering (IPO) once we have a working prototype generator and have become a profitable company, selling licenses to our fusion energy technology. We’ve always told investors that this would take some time and that any money they invested would have to be considered long-term. Of course, for our earlier investors, this has become longer-term than we expected. As we’ve often explained, limits on finances and the resulting limits on staffing have been a big factor in slowing our progress. Understandably, some investors have asked us why we don’t have an early IPO to allow investors to realize their profits. After all, our stock has appreciated fifteen-fold over the lifetime of the company. An IPO would make our shares tradable on the stock market, which they are not now.
However, in recent months the experiences of the first two fusion companies to have publicly traded shares have dramatically illustrated the drawbacks of early IPOs. On July 13, General Fusion became the first fusion company to have its own IPO. It did this through a merger with a SPAC, a shell company designed for buying companies and taking them public. General Fusion has long been controlled by investors, so this was a decision taken by the business owners, not by General Fusion’s founder and lead scientist, Michel Laberge.
The deal valued the company at $ 1 billion, and General Fusion got $400 million in cash from it for the next stage of their research. However, this was a very low valuation, considering that the company had previously raised $600 million in cash. So, the valuation was just equal to the total cash raised. By contrast, LPPFusion’s investors value the company at about 8 times cash raised, somewhat more than the average of 6 times cash for companies with our $100 million valuation. For billion-dollar companies like General Fusion, the average valuation is around 12 times cash raised. Thus, the IPO valued General Fusion at a fire-sale price.
Since the IPO, there has been a considerable sell-off as early large investors, who decided on the deal, took their profits. The share price fell from the IPO price of $10 per share to the present $7.50 per share. This performance means that it will be quite difficult for the company to raise more funds in the future, as investors generally count on a rising share price to compensate for a start-up’s risk. In this case, there was clearly a conflict of interest between the short-term profits of the early investors who controlled the company, and the long-term prospects for success of the fusion technology.
In another case of apparent conflict of interest, TAE announced August 5 a deal with Black Moon Energy to supply the company with helium-3 from a future large-scale mining operation on the moon. For decades, TAE has focused on developing a fusion energy generator using hydrogen-boron as a fuel—the same fuel LPPFusion is aiming to use. This fuel is abundant and cheap here on Earth. In contrast, He3 is extremely rare on Earth. Mining it on the surface of the Moon, if feasible at all, will certainly take many decades to realize.
Why would TAE pivot from trying to use a cheap and available fuel to what would be an expensive one, available– if at all– only decades in the future? We can’t be sure, but as we reported in December of last year, TAE merged with Trump Media, becoming part of a publicly traded company in an IPO of sorts. The Trump family, which owns Trump Media, has not made secret of its unlimited love for oil and gas production. The effect of a TAE pivot from pB11 fuel to He3 is to redirect one of the largest fusion energy companies away from a fuel that could greatly compete with high-priced fossil fuels and toward a fuel that could not possibly compete with oil and gas for several decades, if at all. Again, the merger that allowed TAE investors to sell their shares on the stock market also created conflicts of interest that may well end any chance that TAE’s technology will ever produce fusion energy.
In contrast, we set up LPPFusion in a way that guarantees it can never be controlled by those who may have conflicts of interest, as voting shares are not for sale. Our plan to hold off on an IPO until we are making a profit on a tested product will protect the interests of both present and future investors. While we certainly understand the desires of our early investors to realize returns on their wise investments, maintaining our independence and postponing an IPO is the only route to actually achieving fusion energy production.
